I watched two of my favourite movies the other night. First I watched the wonderful Annie Hall, probably to this day the best film on relationships between men and women I’ve ever seen. I then watched Four Weddings and a Funeral, a film that satisfies my strange penchant for Hugh Grant films, despite the ghastly character/performance/presence of Andie McDowell.
Back to Annie Hall. I love it so much. But it does make me a bit sad when I watch it. Seeing two people kind of fall into being together, and then watch as something that you’re not sure they should ever have had together develops, then falls apart, and then becomes something really really significant to both of them makes you think.
I was sitting smoking a cigarette on the front step afterward and I had a thought. What if I’m as bad as Alvy Singer (or any other Woody Allen ‘character’) at relationships? It is a serious possibility. My destiny could be to meander through life trying not to fuck up too much, before eventually dying alone thanks to my lack of affinity with cats.
You see, I think relationships really are funny things. I mean, how often do circumstances, mood or timing (or level of inebriation) lead us into something, and before we know it, we are in a relationship we had never planned or envisioned happening? And then, it’s all down to us to work with the raw material… Sometimes, you do just fall into something without even realising it, and then you can’t imagine not having it. Then, when it is gone, truly gone, and you move on, you can’t imagine being there again.
Annie Hall makes me see how this can happen. I fall for ideas of people in my head all the time. A great post I read by Annie Rhiannon made me smile. It reminded me of those times when you see someone and a story in your head makes you think for a fleeting second that they could be your soul mate. It’s not a real voice most of the time, just a subconscious narrative that makes your toing-and-froing a little bit more interesting from time to time. But sometimes, when you are in a whimsy of day-dreaming, imagining an odd hypothetical fate, someone catches you unaware and asks you out. Then, you have a something. And I suppose it’s real. You know nothing about each other, but all of a sudden all your concentration goes into the other person and finding out about them. Then your trusts, fears, hang-ups, opinions and crutches become magnified by a giant lense pointed at you by someone who is deciding whether you can make the jump from potential sex-partner to possible-dating person. Or if you get rellegated altogether to one-off mentaller. I think about this stuff, and have a constant inner monologue, which is why I worry about my lack of affinity with cats…
I like Annie Hall because I like the characters. They are flawed, obsessive, neurotic, charming and interesting. They’re not perfect, but you want it to work out for them. You feel like they’re as bad as it all as you are, and they’re what your hope is riding on. When it ends, it’s sad. Because you realise that people like Annie and Alvy are good people, flawed people, people who try hard, people who make mistakes. They are like you. And you were rooting for them the whole time. Then, to make things worse, you watch Four Weddings and watch that adulterous posh American slut come in and mess Hugh around for an hour and a half, steal the love of one (awesome) woman’s life (Kristin Scott Thomas) and ruin another woman’s wedding day in the process. And she gets a happy ending when she turns up (in a trenchcoat without a scrap of make-up on i might add) to his wedding, spoils everything and then turns up (unannounced) at his house hours after he got decked by the girl he left at the alter. And then she says that awful line…Bitches like her are just the type to be standing in the lashing rain and not even notice. I’d probably get splashed by a muddy puddle as Hugh sped past me on his way to see that curly-haired harlot, or struck by lightning as I rang the doorbell.
But we keep going. We look (and when we do we won’t find, it’s the law), we give up (then it comes…), we are oblivious (when it is staring at us like a giant doe-eyed puppy), we try (all the wrong things), we fight (about nothing), we say sorry (without understanding why), we make up and give it another go (without understanding why), we break up (and down), we move on (and start again), we swear we’ve learned our lesson (we haven’t.)
The last lines of Annie Hall really hit the nail on the head for me when it comes to relationships. Woody Allen is narrating and he talks about meeting Annie about a year after they split up for good: I thought of that old joke, y’know, the, this… this guy goes to a psychiatrist and says, “Doc, uh, my brother’s crazy; he thinks he’s a chicken.” And, uh, the doctor says, “Well, why don’t you turn him in?” The guy says, “I would, but I need the eggs.” Well, I guess that’s pretty much now how I feel about relationships; y’know, they’re totally irrational, and crazy, and absurd, and… but, uh, I guess we keep goin’ through it because, uh, most of us… need the eggs.